The Fallout of Nigeria's Spectacular $25 Million Museum and the Benin Bronzes

Museum exterior Protest at museum
Visitors and officials looked on as demonstrators entered the West African Art Museum in the city of Benin

The nation's remarkable new West African Art Museum (Mowaa) has landed in the center of regional political struggles during the period it was expected to – but was unable – to open its doors to the general public for the first time.

The Major Initiative

The six-hectare complex is located in the heart of Benin's urban center, capital of the southern state of Edo – and features an excavation site and facilities created by celebrated British-Ghanaian architect Sir David Adjaye, particularly noted for the National Museum of African American History and Culture that opened in Washington DC in 2016.

It has been half a decade in the development – and is planned to honor both the history and the modern times of artistic expression in the area famous for the Benin Bronzes, historical pieces looted from the king's palace by British soldiers in the 19th Century.

Preparation and Promise

It is remarkable – and ahead of the scheduled opening, Mowaa was active with workers determined to show it is a place that can match established museums and galleries in the West.

Within art restorers precisely opened art pieces from secure wrapping, examining each piece and taking detailed documentation before arranging them on walls and bases.

Specialists calibrated climate control systems. In the materials science laboratory, personnel set up devices meant to preserve ancient items.

Financial Backing and Economic Vision

The initiative has been the brainchild of investor Phillip Ihenacho – now Mowaa's chief executive.

"I aim us to have a significant economic benefit on communities in the vicinity," he told the press, mentioning that he aspired to make Benin City "a tourism center."

Mowaa, a non-profit local organization, sees itself creating over 30,000 work positions and providing over $80m per year to the local cultural industry through alliances and activities.

Financial Support and Government Issues

It has needed $25m to achieve this stage – funds gathered from different contributors, including the European governments, the British Museum and the Edo state government.

But at present the regional administration has withdrawn support from below it – canceling the use of the property on which the facility was constructed.

An official representative explained this was because in the initial documents it had identified as the Edo-named institution – and it had since dropped "Edo" from its name.

Unrest and Official Response

This announcement was preceded by demonstrations on Sunday, when people entered the campus insisting it be designated the Benin Royal Museum.

A rowdy group insulted foreign guests at the facility ahead of the opening – forcing them to be hurried away under security protection.

Head of state Bola Tinubu has even become involved to attempt to settle the conflict, setting up a special task force to manage the situation.

Governance Issues

But in what way has this become so divisive – and such a reputation problem?

The majority of it comes down to local power struggles at a regional government level, as it was the ex-administrator Godwin Obaseki – whose governance ended last year – who was a primary advocate of the initiative.

And it looks like the government of the current leader, a close ally of the area king, referred to as the traditional leader, may desire increased control in the project. The demonstrators on Sunday, for instance, were insisting that the institution be positioned under the control of the royal leader.

The Cultural Artifacts Debate

This emphasizes the disputed topic of the Benin Bronzes, one of the continent's most celebrated historical legacy.

Because even if the institution does eventually open, these bronzes will be conspicuously absent.

They are brass, ivory and timber carvings that once adorned the king's residence of the historical empire before British soldiers stole them in the late nineteenth century during a military operation.

Nowadays, many stay scattered across museums in Western nations -- such as the British Museum, European center and the American museum.

Return Initiatives

Their repatriation has become one of the most contested discussions in the global art world. About 150 have presently come back – and further are due to follow.

When plans for the museum in the urban center were initially revealed in the pre-pandemic era, the movers and shakers on the national arts community hoped it would become their natural home – a state-of-the-art facility to show them off to the global audience.

But the situation became complicated two years ago after the central administration announced that the traditional ruler would be the legal custodian of returned objects – and the royal household pushed for a facility under the royal family's direct control, contrary to the wishes of the former governor.

Oba receiving artifact Traditional ceremony
The traditional ruler at a gathering in recent years receiving one of the taken cultural objects

Strategic Positioning

This left Mowaa in a delicate position: asserting a definite position on return while remaining diplomatic on guardianship – and stressing its larger purpose, which led to|c

Cheryl Clark
Cheryl Clark

A cultural historian and writer based in London, focusing on modern British society and its global influences.